While
the commercialization of Jazz through promotion agencies like the MCA brought
Jazz to a position of national popularity, it did so at the expense of the
wellbeing of Jazz musicians and even the artistic value of Jazz itself. Inherently tied to the discussion of the loss
of artists’ stake in their earnings and artistic value in Jazz music is the
issue of race. Jazz emerged as a black
art but was steadily being transformed by white artists who had the upper hand
in finding work and dealing with promotion agencies run by white businessmen. Although it was debatable whether white
artists could play as well as the best black artists of the time, it was well
known that the white artists of the time had an advantage over black artists that
was not purely merit based. The discrepancy
in success present as Jazz expanded, which was so obviously based on race, was
the cause of a good deal of debate that was recorded in the discourses between
artists, critics, and magazine writers more frequently than the issue of race
ever had before.
When
Duke Ellington first began his collaboration with Irving Mills to gain him a
place on Jazz music’s national stage through Mills’ platform as a music
publisher and manager, it is doubtful that he knew the scope of the effects
this new kind of relationship between businessman and musician would bring
about to the art of Jazz. Through their
relationship, Ellington was able to land work at New York’s famous Cotton Club
and reach success far beyond that of most Big Band Jazz musicians. The success of this relationship is made most
apparent by Ellington’s popularity surpassing that of his arguably equally
skilled contemporary and main financial competitor in New York, Fletcher
Henderson, “who remained true to the bandleader-entrepreneur model and was
unwilling to hire a manager” (Stowe, David W. Swing Changes: Big-band Jazz
in New Deal America. pg 102). While
Ellington gained much greater recognition and success through his dealings with
Mills, he also cosigned a good portion of his earnings from his musical
endeavors to Mills for his services. For
Ellington and most artists entering promotion and recording deals around the
same time he and Mills entered theirs, the tradeoff in earnings was well worth
the popularity and steady jobs they received.
Soon, however, bigger players would realize the potential profits in
Jazz and make efforts to commercialize the entire Jazz industry, bringing class
and race issues that were previously less prevalent to the forefront of the
discussion of Jazz music.
When
recording companies began to make profits off Swing musicians through recording
contracts and promotion deals, they simultaneously created a demand in the
wider white audience that had not previously existed. Mass demand by whites “worked to the
detriment of black bands by inspiring white imitations of the music that proved
more acceptable to a mass audience” (Stowe, David W. Swing Changes: Big-band
Jazz in New Deal America. pg 122).
The ability of white bands to imitate and better please the new national
audience Swing music had gained undermined what little ability black bands
possessed to make a living in Swing music’s new market. With the art form they had created slowly
being coopted by commercialization, some black artists and proponents of their
cause began speaking out heatedly against the loss of their traditional music
to the white musicians they saw as the driving force of this trend. Some would even go on to claim that blacks’
Jazz ability was superior to whites’, which elicited an equally negative
response from white musicians and led to the heated written debate over race
seen between musicians and critics of the Swing Era.
References:
Stowe,
David W. Swing Changes: Big-band Jazz in New Deal America. 1994
Commented on Rebekah Ent:
This
is a good summarization of the events that occurred as a result of the new
white audience that swing musicians found themselves performing before and the
dialogue the shift in audience created.
You do a good job at identifying the players responsible for much of the
racial tension at the time. I wonder
what you think was the root cause of the shift to a majority white audience? How did Black musicians playing music that
arose from their ancestor’s musical traditions find themselves having to please
an audience consisting, at least partly, of whites that didn’t even think of
them as equals?